"Its okay... save your money and get an Acid!"

Didn't make me a returning customer. It was an ok smoke. Save your money and get an Acid Kuba Kuba..

"Reliable"

Fantastic. Always consistant and smooth. I remember the time they were $20.00 a box. Pre-cigar boom.

"GREAT CIGAR ..HORRIBLE CONSTRUCTION"

This cigar has a great taste. I mean GREAT ...The only drawback is the horrible construction of the wrapper. It falls off , cracks 90 % of the time . Overall WELL worth the price and the drawback.

"Good not Great"

This cigar is good for the price. It has a nice taste and an easy draw but I find that it does not burn evenly and goes out at least twice sometimes 3 times before I finish it. I will still purchase this cigar but will continue looking for that great cigar (price compatable of course).

"An Hour of Bliss."

I wanted to broaden my horizons with a few new smokes so I picked up on one of those Famous Sampler packs. This Hoyo Excalibur was included and boy am I glad it was. The smoke intoxicatingly creamy & delicious with a hint of spice on the finish. I've had about 6 of these in the past year and they have all been fantastic. If you like a creamy smoke this Excalibur is the one.

"Great Cigar! One of the best!"

I have recently just started smoking cigars. When i went to my local cigar shop to get some advice on what would be good to start out on, they suggested the Excaliber I. It was great; it had a smooth drag and a great taste. I will be picking up some from the site to stock my humidor!

"Not Good"

Have been smoking this cigar for a long time. The quality gets worse. The construction has gotten really bad and the price climbs. Will not buy again. A shame. used to be great.

"Best big cigar value going"

After 20 years of cigars, this is the best big cigar value going. There are cigars that are a little better - at twice or three times the price. Nothing in the range appeals to me like a #1 excalabur!

"Fantastic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

I have been smoking cigars for over 30 years and the first Premium cigar I smoked was the Excalibur #1 back in 76 or 77. It was excellent and it drew me into premium cigars. I tryed all different types after that to experience the wealth of the cigar world. I later had another in the early 80's and I must have gotten a hold of the odd bad one but I never returned to them untill recently. I, for a long time had been smoking mostly cubans untill I started to become dissatisfied with inconsitancy issues. Some of my all time favorites like The Cuban Hoyo Double Corona were not up to par. I returned to Dominican-Hondorun and Nicaragauian Cigars. One of the first I went back to was The #1 Excalibur. Utterly Fantastic and far superior to its Cuban Namesake currently; Belive me. Brilliant!!! Tastes like or better then A Cuban Hoyo Double Corona in a great year! I don't have to explain the difference in price at between $70-75/box verses $290 (the price I would pay in Spain for The Hoyo Double-Corona. Everyone who smokes these is smoking the Best there is. I will always be in the search for a superior cigar at some future time, But for now, THIS IS IT! A solid 10

"One of my Favorites"

This is one great cigar for the price. It is hard to beat. Good construction, creamy flavor and solid burn make it a winner everytime!!!