"Love Them"

One of my favorite smokes but I now only purchase them in the stores so that I can feel if they are too tight. The ones that have a difficult draw have a very tight spot close to the mid point of the cigar, if it is there I choose another.

"Bad taste, construction, burn, smoke."

Bought a 5 pack based on the name..big mistake. I've tried 2 now and both have literally fallen apart while smoking them. Dry?..I don't know. Taste was HARSH, almost burning my mouth. Not a nice smoke @ any price .

"Not bad for the price."

I got 5 of these in an auction. The price was right, and for the price they aren't bad at all. Even burn, decent flavor (looked MUCH better than they tasted), but when I lit it my head almost caved in. I tried rolling it, but the wrapper started to come apart. A little spit, and a lot more rolling, and I actually got it to draw acceptably. For what I paid it was a good deal, but if I had of paid full price for them I would have sent them back. Definitely not worth almost $6.00 each. But if I can get them again for the price I paid this time I would buy them.

"Flavorless"

This cigar looks great, burns well, rolled just right, but, has no flavor. If I didn't see smoke coming out of my mouth, I would not have known I was smoking it.

"Great Cigar!!!"

I was impressed by the first one and now after the fourth, my opinoin has not changed. Its draw is what a good cigar should be, not to tight but loose enough that you have to work at it. The flavor is smooth then becomes rich toward the end. Its lives up the the maduro name. I also recommend the Rocky Patel sun grown factory 2nds. Buy a bundle, you cant beat the price and are just as good.

"Tight, Tight, Tight"

I've tried three of these from a 5-pack, and so far they have all been really tight on the draw. One of them was just unsmokable because of it. I wasn't impressed with the taste all that much either. It could be just because of the ring size, but I know that I won't ever purchase these again. Definitly not worth the hassle or the price.

"Sophisticated and Classy"

I've tried them all and keep coming back to the sophisticated and classy taste of the Macanudo Maduro Baron De Rothschild. I am now at the point that it is this cigar or none at all. It is my choice and I have made it.

"Very tight draw"

I have enjoyed several Macanudo Maduros. After enjoying a Mac. Mad. I got in a sampler pack I decided to order a box of Baron De Rothschilds. The draw on the first was very yery tight. I was hoping it was going to be an isolated case, but sadly this has not proven to be the case. I have smoked 6 and all had very difficult draws. Other than that the construction, taste and smell were great.

"Its a Mac, its a maduro, its goooooood !"

If you like maduro and the great Mac taste you gotta try this. Little more medium flavored than the cafe with a touch of maduro sweetness. A good little 35 min smoke.Not quite as creamy as the cafe.

"Awesome Cigar!"

I'm just about done with a box of the Maduro Baron De Roth's and they have replaced the regular Baron De Roth's as my favorite cigar. Great flavor, no after taste, great burn - everything I want in a cigar. By far my favorite cigar now!