"DRY AND BRITTLE"

I have been ordering from this company for years with no problems. Ordered Punch miniatures in the past and they were great. I even ordered the other sizes. This order the first 3 tins were dry and brittle as if they were an old batch. Its the holidays and was too busy return them. I was really looking forward to them since its cold outside and its a quick smoke. sorry if i could give 0 stars i would.

"Very good"

Excellent smoke when you don’t have the time for a large cigar

"overall very good"

Nice miniature cigar when you don t want to light up the full size. Good draw, nice aroma and overall 4.5 ratings out of 5 on freshness when they arrive

"Good little smoke"

These miniatures are good tasting smokes that provides a satisfying short smoke break. Only one issue is that in the last few orders, I am finding several cigars with punctured and/or torn wrappers which renders the cigars to be not smokable. Weird, because up until recently, the quality has been great. I also find that the draw consistency is ok but occasionally I will find one that is a tough draw. Overall, this is a good little cigar, but the QC could be better. Frankly, I like the Excalibur Miniatures better, but not worth 2$/tin more than these Punch Miniatures. Always good service, packaging and delivery from the famous smoke shop.