"Mild and Sweet"

I am pleasently surprised by this cigar, it seems like the perfect morning smoke. The sweetened tip paired up nicely with the Maduro wrapper, not too sweet and not boring at all.

"Quality has deteriorated"

This has been my everday cigar for 6 years and over 100 boxes. No more! Maker has been purchased by large company and quality has gone downhill. No more sweet tip, no more good taste, no more good draw and lots of smoke. Got to find a new one now.

"Still going strong after 5 years!"

This is my third review. After 5 years and close to 100 boxes, I still have not found a better everyday cigar at any price. I smoke various premiums at night, but I am often disappointed in their consistency. The Baccarat Maduro is the same, box after box. Good flavor, consistent draw and reasonable price.

"Everyday Cigar"

I've tried several different brands both expensive and bargain brand, and for the money the Baccarat has become my everyday cigar. I like the slight sweet tip. I have always went for the naturals but won an auction on the Maduro, and "WOW". What a great cigar for the money. Medium body and flavor great draw and that sweetness is still there. My new everyday cigar the "Baccarat Maduro Rothchild".

"Great Taste,Mild, Good Burn, No after taste,fresh"

Great mild smoke, taste is satisfying,no after taste, good burn, great value.....Very enjoyable

"An Excellent Morning Coffee Cigar"

I really enjoy this smoke early in the morning along with a cup of strong, black unsweetened coffee. The construction, burn, flavor and draw have been consistently pleasant. The sweetness of the cigar is not overpowering and there is not the ?chemical taste? that I seem to get from the Java cigars.

"Still good after 50 more boxes!"

I liked these cigars (Rothschild Maduro)when I first smoked them 3 years ago. I gave another review 2 years ago after a dozen or so boxes. Now, two years and about 50 boxes further into this cigar, I still have found no other with this consistency of flavor, draw and construction for even twice the price. Oh sure, some of them are not as pretty or as perfect as some more expensive cigars, but they are consistently pleasant and flavorful, with an easy draw and good amounts of smoke. Baccarat Maduros will continue to be my everyday cigar until I find a better one and, although I keep trying, I haven't yet found one as consistent.

"Absolutely Fine Smoke"

I have smoked several Baccarat cigars with the natural wrapper, but finally got around to trying the maduro rothschild and all I can say is "Wow"! This little baby kicks butt! I've paid several times the price of this cigar for 'top of the line premiums', and the Baccarat Maduro Rothschild can go toe to toe with the vast majority of them. A truly enjoyable smoke, and one I'll be seeking out in the future.

"Terrific short smoke"

Like a lot of other smokers, I started on Baccarat naturals and thought if I had to be stranded on a desert island with only one brand of smokes, it would be Baccarat. I recently decided to try the maduros and found them to be even better. I've smoked thousands of cigars over the last 35 years and I have about 7-10 favorites that I rotate smoking for variety and the Baccarat maduro robusto is now one of those mainstays. A good tightly packed mild, sweet cigar with an excellent draw. Better to use a blade cutter rather than a bullet punch, in my humble opinion.

"Still my favorite after 18 months"

In November, 2005 I raved about the Rothschild 5x50 Maduro after 4 boxes. Now I can say, after an additional 12 boxes, that I still haven't had a bad one. Oh, yes, every now and then one doesn't burn perfectly evenly, but every one has had a smooth draw, lots of smoke, and great taste right up until the time I burn my fingers. I look forward all day to sitting outside with my cigar and having one hour of peace and let go of the day's stress. The Baccarat is my unwinder. If anyone has found a better cigar for a buck seventy-five, I would be surprised.