Showing 11 through 20 of 48 reviews
|
Previous Next
My Father Petaca
"ONE OF THE BEST"
IT S MY GO TO STICK..I AM BIASED ABOUT DON PEPIN/MY FATHER S
GREAT CONSTRUCTION, CONSISTENT FLAVORA ND AROMA
JOHNin STONE MOUNTAIN, GEORGIA
October 2, 2018
|
My Father No. 3
"Terrible burning cigar"
Cigar tunneled the for more then half the stick and I gave up.
Grantin North Dakota
August 18, 2018
|
My Father No. 1
"Great with a cup of coffee"
This is a lovely smoke: rich and complex. The sticks are beautifully constructed with a draw that is right on the money. I m glad I bought a box, and will surely buy another.
Joel Finkelin Chicago
August 9, 2018
|
My Father Cedros Cervantes
"Very Smooth"
Starts out mild but hints of cedar and spice build in the second half. Not the full body taste that I prefer but still quite enjoyable.
Jay Johnsonin Abilene, KS
July 25, 2018
|
My Father No. 3
"Outstanding"
Full bodied, non-bitter, smoke like a cloud of whipped cream, note of cane molasses in there somewhere.
Ed Ferrerin Ft. Lauderdale, FL
November 5, 2017
|
My Father No. 5
"Almost perfect"
Truly flavorful. This cigar is quite a treat. Excellent construction, great draw. Minor degradation of flavor near the last third, but an otherwise perfect smoke.
rin Washington
April 9, 2015
|
My Father No. 1
"Disappointing"
Beautifully constructed. Perfect burn, perfect draw. Nice aroma. Now the bad news. This cigar is a huge disappointment. It s a smooth smoke but there s nothing there. Very dry on the palate with no complexity at all. I had to give high ratings on everything but taste but don t be fooled. There are far better cigars available at a much better price. Even if it was priced the same as a run of the mill hoyo de monterey I would smoke the hoyo.
Will in New York
October 2, 2014
|
My Father No. 5
"Perfection"
What else can I say, I ve smoked hundreds of cigars from dozens of brands. My Father has always been my favorite but the #5? It is without doubt the best cigar I have EVER had the pleasure to enjoy. When you re looking for a perfect cigar look no further than a My Father #5
Jesse in New Jersey
July 17, 2014
|
My Father Cedros Cervantes
"Over rated"
This cigar is ok, but just ok. It is very overpriced for what it is, and there are a lot of cigars out there a lot cheaper, and much nicer. very muddled flavour profile, and not the most consistent burn.
Douglas in New Zealand
April 29, 2014
|
My Father No. 1
"Smooth but lacking in complexity"
During the first third the flavor were jumping all over while never really taking a stand. There was a little cocoa, a little cedar, a little wood, but before you take another puff they re gone...
The drying tobacco finally settled around the midpoint, with a medium body and very soft notes on the palate, and occasional flavors of cocoa and bitter chocolate. Sweet mint then started building up on the retrohale, reaching the sweet spot around the nub.
In retrospect, I think this medium to full-bodied cigar would be best enjoyed on a warm evening.
89-90 points
Stefan in City by the Bay
April 20, 2014
|
Your Privacy Choices