"Just a mediocre overpriced cigar"

Build quality and attention to detail just not here... I ve smoked $3 cigars with better build. Quality of tobacco and smoke I just couldn t get any notes of really anything, very bland. Burn quality here was uneven and had to re-light a couple times. Patel quality has just become hit or miss and declined over the years. This is an overrated and extremely overpriced cigar. I had higher expectations. Don t waste your hard earned money on these.

"Really liking this cigar"

I ve been into Connecticut wrappers lately. I m really loving this cigar. What I like most is the big size and the taste. Appearance color and Sheen are above average but the size is first impression which is great. Consistency is above average. Draw is excellent. Burn is very good. Looking at it at it now at the two third point and it s very consistent. Construction is very nice. Finally The Taste, This is the part I love. the last 1/3 is excellent! . To me it just tastes like a good strong cigar with great taste it gets better the farther it burns. Sorry I m not very good at figuring out the chocolates and nuts and berries that it taste like. Bottom line is I love the taste, construction is great and the 60 ring guage feels great. Smoking this you re smoking a real cigar.

"Golf course smoke .....check"

Bought a box!

"Delicious"

If your looking for a stick that wont burn the hell out of your palate, this RP is for you. Well constructed, even burn, creamy, dense smoke feel. Lasts approximately 1.5 hours. Thoroughly enjoyed it, hope you will too.

"Mild Rocky so-so puff"

Very nice construction, smooth full draw, even burn. The good stops here. On travel to Nor Cal Xmas time 2012. Stopped and pu a couple of sticks, t last 2. Owner said they've been sitting in the humi room for a year. Mild to weak flavor, very uninteresting puff. I'll give the 1999 Sixty 2.5 stars out of 5. The 2nd will rest in the humi for 18 mos minimum. If like other vintage Rocks, it should mellow and elevate during this time, hopefully.

"My favorite RP thus far."

I only give this cigar to my BEST friends.

"WOW"

What a great smoke a bit larger then I'm use to but great flavor and quality.

"You let me down ROCK..."

I was expecting , I don't know, something "nice" from the Rocker. I've smoked almost everything he puts out and in almost every case one could say that there was something Unique, something.. "Rocky" to each smoke. I bought these because they Looked nice ..with their light color and satiny sheen ,,, the way they're made. But I was really let down. The smoke was almost tasteless except for its Hot, Acidic, Sour , Eye Squinting Harshness. I kept waiting for a saving Second Third but it got even Worse. I couldn't last to the last third. I tried another one days later thinking that I may have gotten the EXPECTED Rotten Apple of the Bunch but with almost identical results. I'll stick with THE EDGE for now thanks...