My Father The Judge Reviews


Showing 1 through 7 of 7 reviews


My Father The Judge Robusto
"Formidable stick, but overhyped"
I really wanted to love this stick, mainly because the name sounds cool and it looks good in a humidor, but also because it got rave reviews on how chocolately it is. And I love chocolate notes. As expected, it s smooth, creamy, chocolately and peppery, excellent draw. But it s like, too smooth. Maybe if the wrapper was sun grown, it would have been perfect. I was like forget it I m just gonna sit back and enjoy how smooth and creamy this is, but then 2/3 s down the nicotine started to get way too strong. I don t know if my palate isn t refined enough to enjoy this fully, or if I just prefer bolder flavor, but this one was a miss for me. No doubt this is some premium tobacco, and I could see how others could dig this. Hopefully I ll like it more after aging it for awhile. Still, My Father, The Judge is such a cool name that I wish I could ve said was in my top 5.

RJ Lopezin Denver, CO
October 20, 2020
My Father The Judge Robusto
"5 star"
Outstanding!

Mike Oin Clifton Park
September 4, 2020
My Father The Judge Toro Fino
"Fantastic Smoke"
I normally like infused, specifically Drew Estates, Isle Del Sol, Ambrosia Spice, etc.. Received this in a sampler pack as it is out of my price range, but WOW... absolutely the BEST non-infused smoke I ve ever had ! They say Full Flavor , but to me, it was mild, probably due to the quality. Nice shape, kind of squarish , and wrap was perfect, tight, but not too tight, and perfect draw. If it wasn t above my pay grade, would be buying these regularly.

Michaelin Idaho
August 16, 2020
My Father The Judge Toro
"Great look, taste and draw. I really enjoy this stick"
Awesome Smoke. Take some time to really enjoy this one.

Leonard Goldenin Bryans Road Maryland
November 30, 2018
My Father The Judge Robusto
"excellent cigar"
has great taste extremely good cigar

howard hokein evansville, indiana
April 6, 2018
My Father The Judge Toro Fino
"Not a bad stick. Good flavor nice burn."
I am a huge fan of the Jaime Garcia sticks. This stick is pretty different. Good flavor, draw, burn. Very nice construction as always with My Father cigars.

Nick Brownin SC
January 23, 2018
My Father The Judge Robusto
"Big Ring, Big Flavor = Perfect"
I do not normally like bigger cigars but I wanted the robusto shape, this 60 ring gauge was a full on flavor bomb from start to finish. It had a familiar peppery font forward cigar but also had some great coca and nutty smoothness to it. I fully enjoyed this cigar and will be ordering more of the Garcia greats!!

Richard T.in Minnesota
December 19, 2017
Average Customer Rating

Another quality site for cigars from
Cigar Brands | Boxes | 5-Packs | 10-Packs | Bundles | Samplers | Singles | Humidors | Accessories
Closeouts | One Day Auctions | New Today | Ending Today | Ending Tomorrow | English | Yankee
My Auctioneer | My Watch List | Shipping Rates | Help | Contact Us | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2020. CigarAuctioneer.com All Rights Reserved.
[email protected] | 1-800-656-1911

Famous Smoke is a secure retailer of the finest cigars online at the web's best prices. Please note that Famous Smoke Shop does not sell tobacco products to anyone under the age of 21 (or the minimum age in your local jurisdiction, whichever is higher). Note also that it is unlawful to even attempt to purchase cigars below the minimum age. If you are not of legal age, please do not enter our site. For more information on how we verify age click here.