February 8, 2021
"Disappointment From An Old Favorite"
I m afraid I ll have to agree with Tom in NJ.
This was a favorite of mine and had always performed well. This last batch was like trying to smoke a pencil. There s a chance it will stay lit... but it ain t worth it. No draw at all.
Also, each one badly canoed regardless of the smoking environment and the cut used.
Here s hoping the criticism will lead the maker to correct the issues. I ll try another one in a year or so.
Michael Simonsin IN
September 1, 2020
"Smoked these many times before never again"
I smoked only 2 out of 10 so far. It is like sucking a golf ball through a hose, I throw them away after a short time.
tom lukowiakin 1201 holly lane cedar grove nj
August 1, 2018
"Out of 10 cigars, 2 lost most of their wrappers taking off the cellophane."
Harlow Freebergin 2132 Cty rd E East
November 28, 2017
"A great cigar, mild yet full of taste"
This cigar is one of the best I've had. An even draw, well constructed, mild and yet full of flavor, not a burnt taste. One of the most consistant cigars made. Always even, never a hard draw. If you have complaints about the preceding, you should adjust your humidor. One of the best for the money, I have paid much more for inferior quality as compared to this Macanudo.
Michael Liloia in Brick, New Jersey
February 4, 2000