"Amazing stick, amazing flavors"

First of all, I should have let them sit for just a bit more after shipping but I was too excited. So I had a few burn issues with the wrapper probably being a bit too moist, but that didn t even matter, the flavors were astounding. I don t normally taste flavors in a cigar, such as coffee, or chocolate or cream or anything like that. I can honestly all of the sudden about halfway through, I had the most insane flavor of chocolate and coffee that it was just impossible to ignore, and I wasn t even looking for the flavors, they were just there. Even with the burn issues, I m gunna let the rest sit for another week and they will probably burn perfectly and taste even better which is hard to imagine. I bought a 5 pack but I ll probably be buying a box after this.

"Great cigar..."

Very good cigar..loved it

"Grunt Grunt Snarl!!!"

This is probably my favorite cigar right now. Full Flavored, full bodied, and a perfect roll every time. It lives up to the CroMagnon image, ie you don t have to have a big brain to love this cigar. And just like GEICO, loving this cigar is so easy a caveman could do it...

"All I Can Say is “WOW”"

I’m just going to preface this review with the fact that it takes a really good cigar for me to write a review. And it takes even more for me to be blown away by a cigar. But this one is fabulous. Several years ago I decided life was too short to drink average liquor/wine and smoke mediocre cigars. And this cigar truly stands out from the crowd. The Cromagnon Maduro 5 is complex, well-made and beautiful. I would recommend it to anyone has an advanced palate and wants to smoke a really, really good cigar!

"Great Maduro"

A taste and profile that is strong and delicate at the same time. Maduro Fans rejoice and non Maduro fans you may change your tune after trying this connoisseurs delight.

"Amazing smoke. Needs age."

Stunningly rich flavors. Nutty, bright and complex. However bitter spells through the 2nd half scream for rest. This will be a great cigar in a year in the humidor. Until then, it is worth barely above it’s low MSRP in my opinion.

"Always solid medium to full"

Classy smoke, interesting layers of flavor. Not as complex as Nanderthal. Yet, more affordable. I prefer the smaller Knuckle Draggger in the Co-magnum format. Roma Craft are excellent across the board for the money.

"Absolute favorite"

Just spent a week in St. Maarten smoking a variety of Cubans, some real and some no doubt fakes. Couldn t wait to get home to burn a Mode 5! Strong, smooth, complex, great in every way.

"Simply stunning!"

For me, it s the best tasting, best constructed cigar I ve had the honor to smoke -- and I ve been at it for 3+ decades!