Onyx Reserve Cigar Reviews at Famous Smoke Shop

Our Customer Reviews for

Onyx Reserve Cigars

Great smoke


I bought a 5-pack of these not too long ago. After smoking the first four, I felt the same way as J Friedman. They were horribly harsh; pretty much unsmokeable. I left the fifth one in my humidor until it was the last cigar I had (because I hated them). It sat for about a month and a half, and it was the best smoke I've ever had. I DEFINITELY recommend letting them sit for a little while.

This review was written about Onyx Reserve #4 by Ian G of Salem on August 2, 2010



Incinsistent draw


I bought a box about 4 months ago. Down to the last 2 and the draw has been very inconsistent on them. Some the draw was perfect and when it is this is a great cigar. Others, probably 4 or 5 of the box, are very tight. Running a darning needle thru them and cutting them back did not help much. Almost unsmokable

This review was written about Onyx Reserve #4 by Rich M of Wi. on July 31, 2010



Bad draw and burn, Great taste....


I thought I would try these and like the other reviewers this cigar has a very bad draw and gets impossible after lit. If that is not bad enough it started to burn down the middle of the roll and became hot at the mouth even with only 1" burned off the end. However the wrapper burn looks fine and uniform. You can see the small burn down the middle by looking at the end (about the diameter of a small soda straw). I have never seen a cigar do this before.

This review was written about Onyx Reserve Mini Belicoso by Craig of VA on July 21, 2010



Wish I didn't have 9 more to smoke


Everything about this little cigar is great except for the taste. There was a lack of taste and what was there was dull nutty/woody. I know, that doesn't sound that bad but it's only because I'm not good at describing it. I thought that maybe my palate just wasn't ready for it. So I swished some water around to sort of start fresh. But the cigar tasted the same. Now I'm stuck with 9 more. Would have rather lit an Ugly Coyote.

This review was written about Onyx Reserve Impulse (10) by Rick of  on July 16, 2010



One of the best


This is one of those cigars that I'll smoke to the nub and be tempted to light up another. I've smoked a lot of cigars in my time, but this is one I'll always buy a box of when I run out. I can't believe this isn't an 8 dollar or higher cigar. Great from start to finish.

This review was written about Onyx Reserve Toro by Mike of Chapel Hill, NC on July 6, 2010



View all 144 customer reviews
RSS: Hot Auctions at Cigar Auctioneer!
RSS: Cigars on auction from CigarAuctioneer.com  RSS: Cigars on auction from CigarAuctioneer.com  RSS: Cigars on auction from CigarAuctioneer.com  RSS: Cigars on auction from CigarAuctioneer.com  RSS: Cigars on auction from CigarAuctioneer.com  RSS: Cigars on auction from CigarAuctioneer.com 

Home  |  Cigars  |  Samplers & Packs  |  Humidors  |  Accessories  |  On Sale Now  |  Our Catalog  |  Auctions  |  My Account  |  Info  |  Store

Copyright ©2010. CigarAuctioneer.com All Rights Reserved.